Pashmina shawls have Shahtoosh guard hair, say Customs officers; all fluff, counter merchants and artisans

Out of date testing method resulting in ‘false optimistic’ for presence of banned Shahtoosh guard hair, say merchants

Out of date testing method resulting in ‘false optimistic’ for presence of banned Shahtoosh guard hair, say merchants

Merchants of universally-prized Pashmina shawls are complaining that “out of date testing strategies” have resulted in a lot of their export consignments being flagged for presence of ‘Shahtoosh’ guard hair, which is obtained from endangered Tibetan antelopes. The merchants declare the usage of out of date strategies comparable to ‘Mild Microscopy’ by the authorities has resulted in a number of circumstances of ‘false optimistic’ resulting in their wrongful prosecution.

Pashmina is obtained from breeds of mountain goats ( capra hircus) discovered within the Changthang Plateau in Tibet and components of Ladakh, within the Himalayan area of India.

Manufacture of Pashmina is a largely unorganised cottage/handicraft business offering employment and livelihood to roughly 6 lakh individuals, most notably to native expert villagers and artisans in Kashmir.

Shahtoosh, however, is the superb undercoat fibre obtained from the Tibetan Antelope, identified domestically as ‘Chiru’, a species residing primarily within the northern components of the Changthang Plateau in Tibet. As they provide excessive ranges of smoothness and heat, Shahtoosh shawls turned a extremely costly commodity.

Sadly, resulting from industrial poaching of the animal, their inhabitants declined dramatically. CITES (Conference on Worldwide Commerce in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna & Flora) included the Tibetan Antelope in 1979 resulting in prohibition in sale and commerce of Shahtoosh shawls and scarves.

Tough to distinguish

As the 2 supplies have related bodily properties and tangibility, differentiation is difficult with out superior scientific forensic strategies.

Naqeed Qazi, a Pashmina dealer, has first-hand expertise of one in every of his export consignments of Pashmina shawls getting flagged by Customs authorities for presence of Shahtoosh. “I had sought DNA testing of the consignment however my enchantment was rejected,” Mr. Naqeed stated.

The pattern from his consignment was as a substitute despatched to the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehradun, which employs Mild Microscopy method to search for the presence of Shahtoosh. Mild Microscopy methodology, Mr. Naqeed stated, “was subjective and depended to a big extent on the experience of the examiner”.

“My case then concerned the CBI. The company got here to my workplace in Kashmir and went to the artisans. Although they had been very skilled and there was no harassment, for a typical dealer or weaver, CBI knocking in your door is an enormous factor,” he stated.

“Now, Enforcement Directorate (ED) has received concerned within the case and they’re trying into the cash laundering angle. That is all being executed on the idea of 1 mistaken take a look at,” Mr. Naqeed rued.

One other Pashimina dealer, Imran Rashid, stated as a result of “prevailing system” a variety of export orders get cancelled because it takes months – in some circumstances years – for the cargo to finally get launched by the officers.

“Until this entire means of testing is over, the cargo is mendacity with the Customs. It’s rotting and the shoppers will not be going to attend for that lengthy. Because of this, the worth of Pashmina exports has dropped from over ₹750 crore about 6-7 years in the past to about ₹100 crore right this moment,” Mr. Rashid acknowledged.

He commented that as most of the exporters don’t want get into this type of hassle, many have stop the export-end of enterprise and are focussing on retail. “That’s why there may be such an enormous dip in exports,” he defined.

“That is hurting the cottage business which employs virtually 10 lakh individuals immediately and not directly. Out of those, 6 lakh are artisans – weavers, embroiderers, and many others. Principally, the grassroots stage of society has been hit arduous since exports are declining. Individuals would clearly wish to not enterprise into one thing which is simply too dangerous. We’re speaking about critical felony and civil prosecution right here,” he stated grimly.

Mr. Rashid stated many exporters dealing with prosecutions have numerous experiences of conflicting outcomes of the federal government’s personal forensic reviews.

An artisan in Kashmir crafting the Pashmina shawl

An artisan in Kashmir crafting the Pashmina scarf
| Picture Credit score: SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT

HC moved

Left with no different choice, the Pashmina Exporters and Producers Affiliation has moved a petition earlier than the Delhi Excessive Court docket, for a course to enhance the present testing infrastructure by incorporating the trendy ‘Scanning Electron Miscrospcopic’ method and DNA checks.

Advocates Tanveer Ahmed Mir and Kartik Venu, who represented the affiliation, stated that the anomaly within the forensic outcomes adversely impacts the Pashmina business at massive reputationally and economically.

Mr. Mir stated that the merchants are subjected to each Customs prosecutions – on suspicion of presence of Shahtoosh guard hair – in addition to felony prosecutions by Wildlife Crime Management Bureau (WCCB), CBI, and ED probably resulting in incarceration as much as seven years, even when it isn’t clearly proved if the fabric used is in actual fact a contraband.

BIS for Pashmina

India contributes solely about 1% of the world’s Pashmina, however the Pashmina produced in India is taken into account the very best of the lot and occupies a singular place.

As a result of restricted availability and excessive costs, adulteration of Pashmina with sheep wool/ultra-fine merino wool is a typical follow by producers. In 2019, the Bureau of Indian Requirements (BIS) revealed an Indian Customary for identification, marking and labelling of Pashmina merchandise to certify their purity.

In 2021, the BIS launched a revised report titled ‘Identification, Labelling and Marking of Pashmina Merchandise’ that mandated instructions for incorporating qualitative and quantitative identification of Shahtoosh guard hair.

The Pashmina merchants say the BIS testing requirements are nonetheless to be carried out by the forensic authorities.

Leave a Comment